Suspected Arson Destroys Butler Island Landmark

A partially collapsed brick structure in the foreground with a damaged wall, surrounded by tall grass and palm trees, while in the background, remnants of a burnt building are visible.

Friends from Darien have just called to tell me that the historic Huston House, built on Butler Island in 1927, is engulfed in flames. The Huston House is a landmark of McIntosh County and Highway 17, the Georgia home of Col. Tillinghast L’Hommedieu (T.L.) Huston, a part owner of the New York Yankees. Babe Ruth spent time at this house during that era.

Before Huston’s association, the Butler family owned this land from at least 1790 until 1923. Their rice plantation was dependent on the labor of as many as 500 enslaved people at its peak. Multiple generations of families were chained to this land and many were buried here, as well. As the plantation declined, most of the Butler enslaved were sold at a Savannah racetrack between 2-3 March 1859, in what came to be known as the Weeping Time. Their sale to disparate buyers ensured that most would never see each other again.

A large white house with a dark roof surrounded by palm trees and a grassy field under a partly cloudy sky.

In recent years, ownership has shifted between state and local sources and its future has been uncertain.

A scene depicting the aftermath of a building fire, with charred remains and debris scattered in a field surrounded by palm trees.

Update: A visit to the site this morning (27 June 2024) confirms that the house is a complete loss. A news story from WSAV states that a person of interest (not a suspect) is in custody. I also hoped it was a lightning strike and am really sad to hear arson is suspected.

3 thoughts on “Suspected Arson Destroys Butler Island Landmark

  1. Christopher Paul Morris's avatarChristopher Paul Morris

    Was the house being used in any capacity?

    I’ll miss seeing the house; for me it was always the harbinger of my approach to Darien.

    Reply
  2. Cindi's avatarCindi

    I am stunned by this. Truly stunned. Captain Butler’s wife hated slavery. She kept a diary. She went to Sea Island in boats alone with them. You can’t erase history by burning it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply