
Brantley Church was established in 1854, when this settlement was known as Red Bone. A local historic resource survey dates the present structure to circa 1860, though this attribution cannot be independently verified at this time. The vernacular architectural style is consistent with buildings of that period. The congregation was originally affiliated with the Methodist Episcopal Church and was later associated with the United Methodist Church. Nettie Howell recorded in her History of Marion County, Georgia (1931) that the Red Bone district was once the site of a well-attended camp meeting and served as an important center of religious activity in the county from at least the 1850s until the late 1870s.

